I need to go over proposal 3 and answer these items :
Proposal 3: Reviewer 1
What elements of this proposal did you like the best and why?
What elements of this proposal did you like the least and why?
How were the proposals similar in their approaches? Different?
If exists, list specific ways in which each proposal was unclear or did not justify their ideas/suggestions.
Explain whether you think the similarities and differences were justified.
If you consider anything else in your evaluation, please list and describe.
I attached proposal 3 itself and the second reviewer work to help you to get ideas how to answer the above items.
I highlighted the items that need to be done . I am reviewer 1